Granny's Scone Recipe 

- handed down through the family, using cold hands.

Here is a foolproof authentic Scottish scone recipe, handed down through generations of Johanna's Highland forebears. To make the best scones you need cold hands - or is that a Scottish baking myth? Johanna's granny made her scones with sour milk but buttermilk will work. And vanilla essence is a modern and faintly exotic addition! 

Johanna's Granny made the best scones

Johanna's Granny
Johanna's Granny - her maiden name was Flora Macdonald. Pictured at Arisaig in the mid 1920s.
Granny's scones
Scones Johanna made using her Granny's recipe
Kate Macdonald feeding hens
Kate Macdonald (nee Gillies - born on Isle of Skye) - Johanna's great-grandmother - feeding her hens in the kitchen garden of her home, Arisaig Hotel - mid 1930s.

Granny's Scottish Scone Recipe.

My granny, Johanna writes, was called Flora Macdonald (1904 - 1991). This recipe came from her mother Catherine (Kate) Gillies who was from Snizort on the Isle of Skye - born in 1879.

Before that, I reckon this recipe and method came from her mother, Flora Gillies, a crofter's wife - who also lived on the Isle of Skye.

Recipe

  • 16oz (450 g) self raising flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • 3oz (80g) caster sugar
  • a pinch of salt
  • 3.5 oz (100g) cold butter or margarine - chopped into small pieces
  • Milk, use whatever kind you have in the fridge. About 10fl oz / 284 mls Granny would use milk she had allowed to go sour - and her scones were always so light and soft - but I haven't tried this.
  • Buttermilk works well - I use a standard carton (284 mls / about 10 fluid oz). Or use ordinary milk mixed with a small amount of lemon juice - then pop it in the microwave to warm through - this works well too. Or just use ordinary milk! I sometimes put a little vanilla essence in too, but Granny never did.

Method

Turn the oven up to 220 C / 390 F (as long as it is hot!). Pre-heat a baking tray.

Sift the flour, salt and sugar into a largish bowl. Rub in the butter or margarine into the flour - until it resembles fine breadcrumbs. Use a light touch.

Or use the food processor. Blitz it! But not for too long - it’s quick in a food processor and you don’t want to overwork the mixture.

Granny had cold hands - this surely helped! (Her pastry was light as a feather too!)

Gradually add the milk mixture - mix with a knife or a metal spoon as this means you don’t overwork the mixture. Do not make the mixture too wet. That’s why it is a good idea not to add all the milk at once.

You will get a feel for when the dough has the right amount of milk. Not too wet, not too dry! Add more milk if you need to. It should all come together in a softish ball.

Flatten the ball gently with your hands on a floured surface. I usually have the ball of dough at least 1.5 inches (4 cm) thick. Too thin and your scones are thin! Remove the hot tray from oven and sprinkle with a little flour.

Cut out your scones - be gentle, don’t over work the scones and they say you shouldn’t twist your cutter - just press down firmly and shake the scone out - and if the cutter gets sticky, dip it in the flour bag.

Place scones on the hot tray and bake for about 10/12 minutes, depending on your oven. I place the tray in the middle of my oven.

Awfully fancy scones
What? Sometimes scones are a blank canvas for flights of fancies, as here in a wee dog-friendly cafe in Berwick-upon Tweed (England). Feta? Olives? What would Johanna’s granny said about them in scones?

These scones are nicest eaten the same day.

My Granny's scones were wonderful - it may have been the sour milk or the knife or her cold hands!

I recall that her scones were always soft and tasty even two or three days later.

I have never quite managed to reproduce that texture. But they toast well - if a day or two old. Try them with marmalade or Scottish heather honey for breakfast!

However, while Granny might have been a great baker, she never entertained the Kaiser and other toffs with her scones. But Mrs MacNab near Balmoral Castle did. Read all about her below…

Mrs MacNab’s Scones - A Traditional Scottish Recipe

As you have read above, lightness, coolness and quickness in the dough-making seems to be key in all of the many scone recipes. Mrs MacNab was a farmer’s wife near Ballater in Aberdeenshire.

That town, of course, is near Balmoral Castle, the royal family’s holiday hideaway in Scotland ever since Queen Victoria had it built.

So great was the reputation of Mrs MacNab’s scones that distinguished guests at Balmoral, including King Frederick of Prussia, used to pop in for tea regularly (or so the story goes.)

This Frederick was really Kaiser Frederick III – the one who married Queen Vikki’s eldest daughter, called after her mother.

I like to imagine Mrs MacNab, passing the scones, desperate for a conversational gambit, saying in her fine Aberdeenshire accent ‘An foo’s yer mither-in-laa?' (How is your mother-in-law.) To which Kaiser Fred would reply. ‘Ach, still ze queen…’

Home baked scones - yum
More home baked scones - yum

Anyway, if you want to attract German nobility with one of the famous recipes from Scotland, this is how you should start:

Mix 16 oz / 454 g flour with a teaspoon of salt, a small tsp of bicarbonate of soda and 2 small tsp of cream of tartar.

Rub in 2 oz / 55g butter. Stir in a beaten egg and a half-pint / 284ml buttermilk.

On a floured board, knead by hand as lightly as possible.

Tear into big enough pieces of dough to enable you to cut them into ‘scone-size’ quarters, having pricked them with a fork.

(This is our interpretation of the original instructions.) But, basically, handle the mixture as little as possible.

It seems that both Mrs MacNab and Johanna’s granny had really cold hands. (So that’s where Johanna got her own cold hands from…trust me.)

Finally, bake in a very hot oven for 10-15 minutes.

Please note: these notes are not given with a guarantee that German nobility will turn up. But you friends will love the baking...

Fancy a shortbread, anyone? Part of the Scottish high tea quite often…

Scottish shortbread - recipes and also geometry

Scottish shortbread, a buttery biscuit or cookie, is iconic like haggis, and still a favourite in Scotland. This page features a couple of easy to bake traditional shortbread recipes including petticoat tails.

Scottish high tea - a hot dish and irresistible baking

Scottish high tea - the carbohydrate Olympics. First a big plate of meat pie, fish, chicken, then a knock-out blow - irresistible home-bakes. Served late afternoon to early evening. Not the same as afternoon tea in Scotland, but a real high tea is getting harder to find.