- hi-tech game show treatment of Scotland’s story
The Bannockburn Visitor Centre in Stirling turns a famous Scottish victory into a giant who-cares-who-wins game show. Still, it’s best not to take sides, eh?
This is my view of the Battle of Bannockburn Visitor Centre, owned by the National Trust for Scotland.
And I have to make it clear from the start I was fed canapes when I was there. And offered wine. It was a trade event. The staff were charming and helpful.
The visitor attraction tells the story of what happened at the Battle of Bannockburn, near Stirling, in June of 1314.
It was a vital clash in the Wars of Independence, and the Scots were the underdogs against the much-fancied English team.
To the Scots, the date is probably the best known date in their history. It isn’t important to the English, as they prefer 1066.
And to the rest of the world, it’s a pretty murky date altogether. (Trust me, I’ve edited guidebooks.)
(Pictured here) Wait, isn’t that King Robert I of Scotland, impressing those two tourism professionals? And – no, it can’t be – yes, it is. It’s King Edward II of England himself, looking very pensive and slightly apprehensive.
Well, from what can be inferred from historical rumours, he wasn’t too keen on chatting to, uhmm, the ladies. Nudge, wink.
Now, the 700th anniversary of the battle that delivered Scotland’s independence for almost four centuries was also the same year that Scotland was given the chance to become independent again.
So, you would think that the National Trust for Scotland would run for miles rather than be seen to be associated with all of the political and emotional ramifications of the idea of independence.
I mean, the Scots’ King Robert won, didn’t he? You know, “proud Edward’s army” of England and all that. He “sent them homeward, to think again”, didn’t he?
Well, they avoided this problem of being seen as partisan with a very clever ploy. They simply treat the battle as a glorified computer game.
Rather cleverly, the designers have avoided anything overtly favouring Scotland by interpreting the battle as some kind of computer game: a kind of make-believe, illusory, flashing, who-cares-who-wins entertainment.
It’s an even-handed approach.
The Battle Of Bannockburn Visitor Experience
So, what do you get for your entrance fee (which some say is pretty steep if you are not a member of the NTS)?
There is a shop selling Bannockburn themed stuff and other stuff as well. In fact, it’s got lots of stuff.
After your browse, suitably batched and timed, you are taken into a kind of high-tech Punch-and-Judy show which gives some historical background, using animated figures. It’s all very clever – almost tongue in-cheek.
Next, the 3D Experience…
Then you go into a circular room, with projection screens all around. You have to wear those weird 3D specs. That’s compulsory. And it’s very dark.
Unless you knew the Battle of Bannockburn was fought in mid-June – the English army set out for Stirling from Edinburgh on the 22nd June to match the 30 or so miles to
Edinburgh on the 22nd June to match the 30 or so miles to the battlefield – you would be forgiven for believing this was a twilight encounter. Maybe it was the glasses.
Anyway, suddenly, there are arrows flashing across your nose, horsemen pounding into the room, swords clashing, soldiers yelling. It’s visual candy-floss. Very 3D and flashy. Quite impressive, really.
(Pictured here) Take off your 3D glasses and suddenly the crepuscular (apparently) Battle of Bannockburn becomes fuzzy as well.
I just want to say here that it isn’t easy photographing something that’s meant to be in 3D with those funny glasses.
And if it all gets a bit confusing or too much then you can go into a wee side corridor, wave your arms at, uhmm, some images of soldiery and they start talking to you. Actually, my powers of description are failing me here.
Pictured here) The Battle table. You don’t get any impression of scale here but it’s, uhmm, like a big round table, only lumpier.
The battle master-person stands, in costume, chain mail and leathery bits, at a console-thing and he/she invites the participants to move projected formations of archers and all the others around until he/she decides one side has won. I think.
Battle Of Bannockburn War Game
Heck, I’m supposed to be an expert on Scotland and I hadn’t a clue what was going on. Please don’t be judgmental.
But wait, there’s more. You can take part in the battle yourself by taking sides at the ‘Battle Table’, where a battle master is in charge to orchestrate the whole thing.
Maybe I just don’t get war games, but I took part, in company with other participants in a circle round the table.
To be honest, by the time it was over, I was both sweaty and baffled, partly because nobody in those days had the advantage of looking down on a battlefield from the equivalent of, oh, about 1000 ft up in the sky above it. Nope. Mystified.
I think the English won when I was there, just to make matters even more unsatisfactory.
Finally, you get some more hi-tech Punch and Judy stuff, about the aftermath, then they all lived happily ever after – not.
And then you emerge, blinking, into the café. Hmm, might have another look at the shop. Oh, a canape? Well, thank you…
(Pictured here) Outside, Robert the Bruce sits distantly and grimly. Around him and his Rotunda, there is mown grass, a swathe of parkland that might, just might, have been part of the battlefield.
He was photographed on a dreich, rainy evening and there were people outside walking their dogs and carrying poop-bags in the way that tries to give the impression these have nothing to do with them. It was the last little surreal touch.
Thank you to the National Trust for Scotland for showing me your Bannockburn Visitor Centre. And you’d rather I was honest, wouldn’t you?
Especially as you have so many brilliantly authentic experiences of landscape and history elsewhere in Scotland.
I’m just not sure that Bannockburn is one of them.
On the other hand, your Culloden Visitor Centre certainly is.
More information about visiting, on the NTS’s own dedicated Battle of Bannockburn website. Remember that if you want the full works, and aren’t just going for say, a coffee in the
restaurant or a wee look in the shop, then entry is by pre-booked time slots.
Here’s a list of Scottish kings. And finally, here are some not over-serious thoughts – actually, whimsical nonsense – about King Robert I (aka ‘the Bruce’) and his battle PR team on that link on this site. (Yes, stay with us!)